thebackpacker.com - backpacking, hiking and camping Welcome to thebackpacker.com
create account   login  
     home : trailtalk
    articles  beginners  gear  links  pictures            

another kind of water purification??

View Messages

Viewing posts 1 to 14 of 14 messages posted.

To add this thread as a favorites, you need to first login.
 

so what do you think....
Found this stuff on a women's hiker yahoo board: steri-pen

Oh, and a link from someone that tested it: steri-pen test

Pretty interesting, but not cheap.
Gemini
1:49:05 PM
3/31/03

yeah, i've heard about those! the thing that made me say "F that" was the price. anyway, whenever i need something purified, i just stick my pinky in it. ta-daaahhh!
lyra
2:01:49 PM
3/31/03

I thought that only made it sweet, lyra?
bitpusher
2:03:52 PM
3/31/03

that too.
lyra
2:06:30 PM
3/31/03

Back to the topic....
Lessee, it costs $200? For $200, you can buy a Katadyn (nee Pur) Hiker, and 5 replacement cartridges, which equals 1200 gallons of filtered water, nearly twice what that thing will purify. Plus the Hiker will remove some bad tastes as well. Sure that pen may kill viruses, but time and time again, you hear people say you don't have to worry about viruses in the water in the U.S. So,if you're going abroad, it might be a good choice, but for backpacking, I don't think so.
bitpusher
2:13:00 PM
3/31/03

I was more thinking about the size, and I am pretty sure it doesn't weigh much either.

Well, I am not going to buy it anyway $200 is just way too much $$$
Gemini
2:27:34 PM
3/31/03

I think it said it weighed 8oz with batteries. That is lighter than the Hiker, but not a lot. Plus I'd be afraid of dropping and breaking the thing. You drop it, you're out $200, you drop and break a Hiker, it's only $50.
bitpusher
2:33:13 PM
3/31/03

I guess it depends on which hiker you drop. The heavy ones break pretty good when dropped, it is just so hard to lift them.
tahoe
4:30:45 PM
3/31/03

steri-pen SP ?
I believe I saw something about it on the Discovery Channel . Interesting idea, I was explaining it to our water plant foreman and asked his opinion. Said the same thing you folks have , a bit too pricey .
mcgrunt
6:49:41 PM
3/31/03

steri-pen SP ?
I believe I saw something about it on the Discovery Channel . Interesting idea, I was explaining it to our water plant foreman and asked his opinion. Said the same thing you folks have , a bit too pricey .
mcgrunt
6:49:55 PM
3/31/03

steri-pen SP ?
I believe I saw something about it on the Discovery Channel . Interesting idea, I was explaining it to our water plant foreman and asked his opinion. Said the same thing you folks have , a bit too pricey .
mcgrunt
6:50:22 PM
3/31/03

steri-pen SP ?
I believe I saw something about it on the Discovery Channel . Interesting idea, I was explaining it to our water plant foreman and asked his opinion. Said the same thing you folks have , a bit too pricey .
mcgrunt
6:50:37 PM
3/31/03

Well, if a whole bunch of people buy it, eventually economies of scale will kick in and the price will come down. So, what everyone has to do is say really great things about it and get everyone else to buy it so that the price for us will be lower.

Personally, I'm going to buy three.

:)
reformed lurker
8:43:29 AM
4/01/03

:D, yeah, personally I am waiting until reformed lurker is buying his 3, and the price will drop way down!!!!
Gemini
8:45:12 AM
4/01/03

<< back to Trail Talk main page

 

Post a Message

In order to post a response to this thread you must first be logged in. If you do not already have an account, you must first create a new account.

 

Login Form

Username:
Password:

 

 

Post a New Thread
Search Threads
Browse Archive

Create a New Account

Trail Talk Main Page