DO NOT LOOK IF YOU HAVEN'T FINISHED HARR Y POTTER!

“Alright everybody, time to spark up a debate... Is Dumbledoor dead and is Snake actually a death eater? Now actually think about this... Think about how Snape didn't kill Harry, think about how Snape didn't kill the Dawrf teacher... or Hermione and Ginny as they were walking by? And for Dumbledoor, why did he trust Snape SOOO much. I mean can Dumbledoor actually be wrong? Did Snape and Dumbeldoor set something up together? AND why would Dumbledoor take Harry on such a dangerous mission to get the horcrux? And why did Dumbledoor freeze harry when harry could have simply killed Malfoy? I mean... what do you guys think lol?


Was it Dumbeldoors intent on having Harry out of the school when the Death Eaters came? Was it Dumbledoors intent on specificaly placing Snape in a place whereeas he can by a spy?
last edited: 8/12/05 7:05:42 PM”

“I think Snape and Dumbledor arranged the whole thing...”

“I think Dumbledore knew for a long that not only would Snape kill him, Snape would have to kill him, in order for good to triumph. He knew all along that Snape was a baddy but fought all attempts to have him removed from Hogwarts because evil would have won otherwise.”

“As much as I want Snape to be evil and see him hanging from his nuts in a tree he has always been the ‘don’t judge a book by it’s cover’ character in the series. Damnit! Dumbldore is dead and gone I think. Someone always dies. I just wonder who’s going to be Harry’s mentor-type of person to help him?

These books are just like sex; you look so forward to it and ya wait and wait and then it’s over too quick…”

“I think it was staged. After Dumbledoor drank the liquid to get the horcrux he was very weak, needed Harry's help, needed him to get Snape. He hung onto the side of that building for a long time and only moments before he could barely stand. I do think it was planned to have Harry out of the building when the Death Eaters came. I think Dumbledoor is powerful enough to cast an enchantment to make himself appear dead, thus the reason he wanted to be burried on Hogwarts grounds...so he could awake and be close to the action when need be. Thus the odd above-ground coffin.

I'm wondering what roll Malfoy will play in the next book. His hesitation to kill Dumbledoor...he might turn good and help Harry in the next book. Then again, if Snape really is evil then Malfoy might kill Snape to help Harry kill he-who-must-not-be-named.

Also I suspect that the initials from the note from the fake horcrux was from Sirius's brother, Regulas Black.

Also since Voldemort feared Dumbledor I believe Snape would too and as big D said over and over and over, he trusted Snape with his life. If someone had to fill the "someone-must-die" in this book, then it must have been Regulus Black...remember he was killed by the Death Eaters (I think) for turning on them. I think part of the reason he was killed was because he stole that horcrux and destroyed it.

Next topic for discussion, Is Snape a vampire?

Think about it...when he assigned the kids the essay on Werewolves on Lupin, when Lupin got back he made them do the essay on Vampires. It would also explain some of Snapes likes for darkness (lives in the dungeon, always closes the windows in his classrooms), cold damp rooms/offices, even his dark appearance. And if he could make a potion for Lupin to not turn into a werewolf, well, maybe he could make a potion that would keep his vampire weakness and desires subdued?”

“well after hearing from you guys... i feel much better... i mean the thought od dumbledoor dieing makes me wanna cry! I'm actually jk so don't think I'm a tool.”

“Try reading at www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com for the hopefuls eho think he pulled a fast one. They have some interesting theories too.”