thebackpacker.com - backpacking, hiking and camping Welcome to thebackpacker.com
create account   login  
     home : trailtalk
    articles  beginners  gear  links  pictures            

Adjustable,COMMERCIAL,ultralight alcohol stove

View Messages

Viewing posts 1 to 18 of 18 messages posted.

To add this thread as a favorites, you need to first login.
 

found this thought it was cool but EXPENSIVE

Seems like a cool concept but the reviewer didn't seem to find it very favorable...
roseymonster
9:41:04 AM
7/12/07

I just bought one of those, and it seems to work fine. The air cut off with a worm gear is really cool. It boils water great, the lid shuts it off easily, and the simmer control really works. I cooked some blueberry muffin mix in a bag last night, using the summer feature, and it was fine, although softer and more moist than in an oven. For $30 bucks its a deal.
idaho bob
12:46:27 PM
7/12/07

Stoves that work at 75 degrees don't always work at 25 degrees.
bacpac
12:48:20 PM
7/12/07

Looks like a great stove to use for hiking the AT.
Adventurist
1:00:36 PM
7/12/07

I def would not use this stove in the winter, but for summer it would work. I don't think these little stoves will do some of my favorite food jobs, like cook steak, fry fish, and toast bagels. For cooking water, they should do just fine, and for baking they should be better than other stoves.
idaho bob
3:08:36 PM
7/12/07

I fry fish with my trangia all the time. Takes longer than other stoves but gets the job done.
roseymonster
3:13:26 PM
7/12/07

Why not use it in the winter? I use my (homemade) alky stoke year-round. This past February I used it when it was 0F. As in 32 degrees below freezing.
techntrek
7:20:15 AM
7/13/07

I have one. Works for me!
southmark
8:00:56 AM
7/13/07

Did a hole in the ground, or pile up something around the alky stove for insulation in the winter.

I haven't had any problems.
chili
8:19:50 AM
7/13/07

I've been winter camping when gasoline stoves were hard to get going, and compressed gas stoves were useless. An alcohol stove would be hard to get the fuel to vaporize and get started. Plus for melting snow for water you need more BTUs than the alcohol stove can put out. The blowtorches win for winter camping, hands down. If an alcohol stove worked, I get you were babying it a lot, being very patient, and not melting snow, and had lots of time to fool around with it.
idaho bob
11:35:59 AM
7/13/07

"An alcohol stove would be hard to get the fuel to vaporize and get started. Plus for melting snow for water you need more BTUs than the alcohol stove can put out."

No. I poured the fuel in, added a little more in the outer primer-pot-stand, and lit the primer fuel. Took slightly more fuel in the primer (full cap instead of half a cap), but it lit up just fine, no tending or fooling around. KEY is getting it off the frozen ground or snow, even better if you put a sheet of tin foil under it too. I also put a sheet around the whole thing, close-fitting to the pot, to keep wind out and heat in to get it to cook better. I do that year-round.

For weekend trips the BTU/weight argument is about even between alcohol and other gas stoves. They are so popular on the AT because the weight is about the same (fuel + stove) for a few days out, with easy resupply every few days. There are few places where you must pack fuel in to last you 4 or more days. Plus the alky stove has almost zero down-time compared to the rest of the gas stoves. It might clog (fixed with a knife point) if you get burned food on the burner holes, but that's the only field repair needed. Nice on a 2000+ mile trip.

My trip in February we had running water, but even if I had to melt snow the alky would have been fine for those 2 days. At the 3 day point gas might take the advantage for snow melting, four days is the cutoff if you don't have to melt.
last edited: 7/13/07 1:43:42 PM
techntrek
1:42:54 PM
7/13/07

So SuperTroll, did you get one?
techntrek
12:21:14 PM
7/16/07

How do you guys simmer with a beer can stove? Do you do the metal muffin tin thing?
roseymonster
12:22:57 PM
7/16/07

The penny stove I built uses a "simmer ring". Seems to work good.
Ramblinrev
12:29:43 PM
7/16/07

Nope...I already have three gas and three alcohol, oh, and an esbit....I just thought others who hadn't seen the stove would like to know it's there...
SuperTroll
12:30:08 PM
7/16/07

brasslite has been making "Adjustable,COMMERCIAL,ultralight alcohol stoves" for ages. it's not the next big thing.
Jimmy san
12:33:13 PM
7/16/07

Actually, it works superb in cold weather. I boiled 16 oz. of water in less than 7 minutes in 11 degree weather. However, it doesn't do well without a wind screen even in low winds this is to be expected though. great stove, great price. Buy the wind screen.
murfkid
1:17:23 PM
1/17/09

<< back to Trail Talk main page

 

Post a Message

In order to post a response to this thread you must first be logged in. If you do not already have an account, you must first create a new account.

 

Login Form

Username:
Password:

 

 

Post a New Thread
Search Threads
Browse Archive

Create a New Account

Trail Talk Main Page


Search

Search thebackpacker.com for:


Ready to Buy Gear?

Sponsored Links

Great Outdoor Sites

Posters



Links

  • Phil's Photo Page

  •