thebackpacker.com - backpacking, hiking and camping Welcome to thebackpacker.com
create account   login  
     home : trailtalk
    articles  beginners  gear  links  pictures            
mtn gal
2:55:31 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Oh for cryin out loud!

Who's impersonating Ice Tea now? 84 words and

no

spelling mistakes?!!

This is getting crazy!
Violin
3:01:16 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
If you have to go "cruising down a hill" on a trail that you know is shared with hikers, it is definately your responsibility to be extra cautious of your actions. You are the most dangerous and unpredictable of the two parties and your alertness needs to match your speed and the terrain.

Other than that, I yield to the downhill hiker.
switchback
3:05:54 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
The "rules" are not arbitrary, they exist to protect all users of the trail and while I might choose to step aside and give right of way to a downhill traveler, I ALWAYS step to the side if I'm the downhill traveler approaching an uphill traveler, it's both the ethical and courteous move. One of my regular hiking locales is Mt. Tamalpais, birthplace of mountain biking and I've come across many a biker but have never had a bad experience. Those on bikes know the rules and generally avoid the trails closed to them and are courteous to other trail users when they meet. Have you ever seen signs saying yield to uphill traffic along hilly roads? To the bikers out there; do the complaints the hikers have sound anything like the complaints bikers have about motor vehicles?
Dunk
3:08:40 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
When hiking, I have determined it is best to avoid trails that are used by bikers. It just works out better for everyone involved.
roseymonster
3:17:44 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
You are all grouping foot traffic into one category. A trail runner is equiped differently and travels at a different rate of speed than an overladen backpacker and so should not be put in the same group as backpackers.

If I was a backpacker going downhill and I encountered a backpacker going up hill then I would yield to the uphill backpacker. Just as I would yield to a uphill trail runner if I was a trail runnergoing downhill. But a trail runner can achieve speeds close to a mtn. biker on downhills and should be treated differently than an backpacker carrying a 3rd their body weight
on their back.

The multi-use trail rules were written by hikers. When mtn. bikes showed up on the scene 15 yrs. ago, the hikers told the mtn. bikers that if they wanted to use the hikers trails then they had to play by the hikers rules. Of course this happened because a few daredevil mtn. bikers had no regard for other people on the trail 15 yrs ago.

Yes without question or care of bodily harm would I stop for a naked woman :).
REPTILES
3:20:44 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
naked people get the right-of-way no matter what!
switchback
3:23:55 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Mountain Gal, please put your clothing back on. Thank you.
ken
3:25:37 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
This applies to backpackers...
It is much more difficult to stop if you're hiking downhill than if you are hiking uphill. Therefore, the uphill hiker should yield to the downhiller. I think it's mentioned somewhere in the Old Testament.

(hmmm... is there an echo in here?)
(o:
gojo
3:26:55 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
i agree, ken. it is getting quite old. and her boobs are reeeally sagging!
radagast
3:30:37 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Flink... If there is any question about your ability to immediately slam on the breaks, you are going way too fast for a multi use trail.
PedXing
3:34:34 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Actually the rule exist to protect the mt. bikers. If those rules aren't followed the mountain bikes will lose more and more trail access. Then we will all be roadies.

I personally, whether hiking or riding, stop and let others pass. Usually it's a great opportunity to take a rest and say,"Hello". Many of the trails that have been closed to bikes were fun to ride when I was a kid. They didn't get closed until a bunch of A Holes discovered mt. bikes and rode like they owned the trail. The fact of the matter is mt. bikes are the new users of the trails, until they can show their out there for more then just tearing up the trail and blowing hikes off the trail, they won't be a welcome site. That is why I go out of my way to make a friendly impression.

This last weekend I went for a ride on a trail close to my home. As I was riding down the trail I noticed a couple of hikers heading up. At about 30 yard from them I stopped and waited for them to pass. When they came up to me, they asked why I stopped, so I explained the "Trail Ethics", they asked some questions about the trails and I help as much as I could. As they walked away they told me they have never met a mt. biker that was this helpful.

I'm betting that encounter was a lot better then having stuff thrown at me. Be an ambassador to your sport not an embarrassment.
LaRock
3:46:20 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
PedXing, you may be right. I'm not the most skilled rider. I really do see the different points of view, but it surprises me because I was just going by what I thought was common sense. Interesting discussion, and it's given me something to think about next time I ride.

mtn gal, that's hilarious! I've never seen such arousing ascii art before! I'd stop for that body, I know that.
Jim Flink
3:46:53 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Gojo, bro, your echo is as incorrect as your original plea.

Yeah, what switchback said!!!!!!!!
naked ape
3:49:03 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Why bother? Let the ears and mind remain closed.
The 'rules' only apply to others.

I've spent plenty of time on a mountain bike and always rode like there could be a toddler around the next bend. If you're not in control, you could be criminally liable. Adrenaline is great but the safety of others should be a concern.
Violin
3:49:27 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Whoops.

Here I go trying to extract my foot from my mouth again. I was writing my cranky message above and was unaware of Jim's 3:46:53 PM post.

Glad to see your mind is open. LaRock seems to have offered some great advice.
Violin
4:04:06 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
America! we are the most messed up country. Only in America do Pedestrians have the right of way. When I was in Kenya i got hit by a car and i learned real quick to stay out of the way. Dont worry just some bruises.

Anyway i agree withg larock You need to just submit to everyone avoid confrontation. Just yieeld to everyone else. that way your not bruised and you dont get yelled at.
adventuregirl
4:04:09 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Violin,
I felt to make my point respected, I would have to use my best spelling and grammar.

I also realized that in the past two weeks, I have been very careless of my spelling and grammar, so I decided its time to go back to my old ?write it, check it, post it? method.
Ice Tea
4:06:57 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Don't sweat it Violin. I'm always having to extract either foot from mouth or head from ass. In any case, I tend to say stuff without thinking.
Jim Flink
4:10:53 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Mtn. gal is our resident flasher. She's got some itches that have gone too long without proper scratchin (tho' she likes to claim otherwise).
PedXing
4:11:20 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Pedestrians should have the right of way. They're the least threatening thing on the road. Unfortunately, American culture has thrust the automobile to the top of the right of way chain (maybe not legally, but drivers in a lot of the country sure act like it). Go to NYC and see what happens if your car crosses the crosswalk. You get a dent in your hood.
roseymonster
4:12:38 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Bikers ought to yield or get the heck out of the woods! I have yet to encounter a mtn biker who was polite and said excuse me before tearing past me and knocking me damn near over. Perhaps its a local thing,only occuring here. I doubt it!

On one hike there was a group of mtn bikers ,lost w/o map. So I help em. No thanks were given. While hiking up a good sized hill with a blind corner ahead I was nearly run down by 1,no 2, no 3, no 4, 7! 7 bikers not one slowed or swerved or anything. I was like a 185 pound obstacle to steer around to improve reaction time. If I hadnt heard the racket of their bikes I would have been hit.

The only difference between horses and bikers is that horses sh!t everywhere, the bikers sh!t on everyone!
hyperpacker
4:17:30 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
T-

Any 15 year old who could swim these waters long has already earned my respect. I only joke about your spelling, I usually know what you mean.

The scouting thing doesn't hurt either. Did I tell you I was an Eagle Scout? How close are you now?
Violin
4:20:58 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Flink I'm glad you are learning something from having asked your question.

I have a mountain bike and know the frustration of not having good places to really move on a good trail. I wish there were more Trails dedicated to mountain bikes. The primary places I get to air it out are on old railroad right of ways... which have the advantage of no blind curves, but they really aren't that challenging or variable (excpet when you have lots of erosion).
PedXing
4:24:26 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Jim, your post made some interesting points and raised more interesting questions.

First off, learn to emergency stop. If you can't stop your bike without skidding or being bucked then you aren't ready for a trail, especially one with multi-use classification. Try dirtcamp.com for some weekend courses on how to control your ride. It would make both you and others around you safer.

The hiker and equine user ALWAYS have the right of way. Granted, this may not be the most logical of positions especially when crusing some single track but it is and should be so. Go to the IMBA site and truly read the trail usage and low impact standards. Commit them to memory. Live by them. Why? Where I live many haven't learned trail etiquite (this includes hikers and equine users) nor knew these rules existed. Because of this, a great battle has begun to 1) keep trails open to bikes and horses 2) educate all users of trails on what to do and not to do 3) and how to use the land responsibly by keeping up on these issues, volunteering for trail work days and working with the politicians and developers to keep space open and create connections to the various reserves.

Let's be frank, we (trail users) all think we are right. This battle also happened in SF, CA some years ago. There the MTB community wasn't as skilled or lucky to maintain trail access in that case. And now, it seems that this discussion and potential battle is becoming more frequent in all areas of the country as trail users become more dense and trails become more scarce.
ww
4:25:00 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Uphill Backpackers always have the right of way. Horses have the right of way over everyone. They spook easily. They don't seem to like backpacks much. As for trail runners - whenever we have met on the trail I have always stepped aside. I figure that with the speed that they are traveling on foot - they can easily injure their ankles or knees. As for bikers - I have run into rude ones and courteous ones. If the courteous ones are coming downhill - I step aside. As for the others . . . . . .

They belong in the misbehaved trail dog thread.
m&m
4:28:20 PM
4/20/01

Jump to Page   |  1  |  2   |  next >>
<< back to Trail Talk main page

 

Post a Message

In order to post a response to this thread you must first be logged in. If you do not already have an account, you must first create a new account.

 

Trail right of way

View Messages

Viewing posts 1 to 50 of 88 messages posted.
Jump to Page   |  1  |  2   |  next >>

To add this thread as a favorites, you need to first login.
 

Trail right of way
New to this forum, and search didn't help.

question: what's the right of way for when a mountain biker encounters a backpacker?

I figured the backpacker better keep the hell out of the way of the bicycle. that's what I do when I hike.

Last weekend, I was trail riding and came around a corner, and a group of three backpackers was walking toward me, and I was riding down towards them. I was in the center of the trail, going pretty fast, and they were already on the side of the trail. I didn't move over much because there was plenty of room, but as I passed one of the backpackers, he yelled something liek "slow down a**hole!" and threw something at me, maybe a nut. It bounced off my chest, and it kind of stung, but I kept on riding, because I didn't want a confrontation just right then.

I thought that was uncalled for. It makes sense to me for hikers to get out of the way of bicycles since hikers are more mobile.

What do you think?
Jim Flink
12:38:08 PM
4/20/01

Trail right of way
New to this forum, and search didn't help.

question: what's the right of way for when a mountain biker encounters a backpacker?

I figured the backpacker better keep the hell out of the way of the bicycle. that's what I do when I hike.

Last weekend, I was trail riding and came around a corner, and a group of three backpackers was walking toward me, and I was riding down towards them. I was in the center of the trail, going pretty fast, and they were already on the side of the trail. I didn't move over much because there was plenty of room, but as I passed one of the backpackers, he yelled something liek "slow down a**hole!" and threw something at me, maybe a nut. It bounced off my chest, and it kind of stung, but I kept on riding, because I didn't want a confrontation just right then.

I thought that was uncalled for. It makes sense to me for hikers to get out of the way of bicycles since hikers are more mobile.

What do you think?
Jim Flink
12:38:18 PM
4/20/01

Trail right of way
New to this forum, and search didn't help.

question: what's the right of way for when a mountain biker encounters a backpacker?

I figured the backpacker better keep the hell out of the way of the bicycle. that's what I do when I hike.

Last weekend, I was trail riding and came around a corner, and a group of three backpackers was walking toward me, and I was riding down towards them. I was in the center of the trail, going pretty fast, and they were already on the side of the trail. I didn't move over much because there was plenty of room, but as I passed one of the backpackers, he yelled something liek "slow down a**hole!" and threw something at me, maybe a nut. It bounced off my chest, and it kind of stung, but I kept on riding, because I didn't want a confrontation just right then.

I thought that was uncalled for. It makes sense to me for hikers to get out of the way of bicycles since hikers are more mobile.

What do you think?
Jim Flink
12:38:20 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
oops. sorry.
Jim Flink
12:38:37 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Jim Flink
baume 66
12:44:39 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Yes, it was uncalled for, but they had the right of way, first based on their being foot traffic to your two wheel traffic and secondly because it sounds like they were traveling uphill to your downhill and thirdly (not really a right of way matter) bikers are supposed to slow going around blind bends. I think most if not all shared trails post that information when possible.
Dunk
12:49:13 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Hey that's interesting, baume 66. I had no idea there was a celebrity by the name of Jim Flink. I live in coastal Georgia and never have been to Kansas City. He looks like a sterotypical cheesey local news reporter - lol.
Jim Flink
12:51:03 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Dunk, I've never seen rules like that posted anywhere. "No bicycles allowed" is about the only sign I've seen posted.

I don't agree with those rules. It seems to me if I'm coming up on hikers from behind, then they would have the right of way since they couldn't see me. But if they can see me coming, it makes sense to me for them to get out of the way. If not because of a rule, then for concern for their health.
Jim Flink
12:54:51 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
I'm not sure who has the right of way. If, however, I ever encounter a biker coming down over the caps of Mt. Jefferson, I will surely yield the right of way for he/she will not be long for this world.
MadRiver
12:56:16 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
I always thought the person going downhill had the right-of-way due to their higher rate of momentum and the harder it is for them to stop. Also, I thought the the right-of-way order goes something like this: motorized vehicles, horses, bikes, hikers.

None the less, the backpackers weren't completely wrong. One should always slow down when encountering other traffic on the trails, even if it is a sweet section of trail and you're in adreneline heaven.
REPTILES
1:07:52 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
The following is the National Off-Road Biking Association's Code of Ethics.

1. I will yield the right of way to other non-motorized recreationists. I realize that people judge all cyclists by my actions.

2. I will slow down and use caution when approaching or overtaking another and will make my presence known well in advance.

3. I will maintain control of my speed at all times and will approach turns in anticipation of someone around the bend.

4. I will stay on designated trails to avoid tramping native vegetation and minimize potential erosion to trails by not using muddy trails or short-cutting switchbacks.

5. I will not disturb wildlife or livestock.

6. I will not litter. I will pack out what I pack in, and pack out more than my share if possible.

7. I will respect public and private property, including trail use and no trespassing signs; I will leave gates as I found them.

8. I will always be self-sufficient and my destination and travel speed will be determined by my ability, my equipment, the terrain and present and potential weather conditions.

9. I will not travel solo when bike-packing in remote areas. I will leave word of my destination and when I plan to return.

10. I will practice minimum impact bicycling by "taking only pictures and memories and leaving only waffle prints."

11. I will always wear a helmet when I ride.
mtn gal
1:15:51 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
here is what IMBA says on thir web page.
baume 66
1:19:13 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
I think at least slowing down is common courtesy...
would you like it if I galloped by on my horse? ...how about if I was cruising by on my big ol four-wheeler(which I don't have, btw)? Whatever your vehicle(boots, bike, or bridle), even if hikers are well out of harm's way, a little caution is important.

I tend to yield on the trail, whether it is a "rule" or not...but everyone could use a little manners lesson at some time or another, I think.

We are all out there to have a good time and what's the rush?
AmyG
1:31:50 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Reptiles, the uphill / downhill right of way scenario you refer to is superceded by the type of traffic Pedestrian traffic gets right of way in all circumstances except one and that is horse traffic. The reason being, a horse is most unpredicatable. As far as uphill / downhill right of way goes, the reason that uphill traffic gets rights of way is because of energy exerted in traveling in the uphill direction.

The hierarchy of right of way traffic:

Horse
Pedestrian (hiker)
Biker
Motorized

However, you may choose to acquiesce.
Dunk
1:35:01 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Here's your answer: link

Agree with the rules or not, they had the right-of-way, yielded to you anyway, and you continued at a high rate of speed. Throwing something at you was definitely out of line but understandable.

Attitudes like "the backpacker better keep the hell out of the way of the bicycle" are one reason why you see so many "No bicycles allowed" signs.

Not risking a confrontation was a good idea - note the super-sized hiking staff the hiker on the sign is carrying. ;-)
Violin
1:37:43 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Downhill hikers have the right-o-way, even to other hikers. The uphiller should step to the downhill side of the trail, especially when encountering horses.
gojo
1:43:03 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Sorry Dunk but that makes no sense at all.
If I'm trail running downhill, I'm suposed skid to a stop so a slow moving uphill hiker can pass me? The danger and the energy required for me to stop is far greater than the energy for an uphill hiker to stop and then start back up again.
Sometimes it's situational though, if someone is really chugging up a hill I will usually stop and let them go, but if they're plodding along more than likely they will get out of your way.

And if I'm driving in my truck on a jeep trail and I see hikers approaching me, I have to pull off the road and wait for them to pass?
REPTILES
1:53:37 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
The cyclist should yield.
bacpac
1:59:26 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
No, No, No, the hiker going up hill always has the right away, because it is harder to gain momentum when going up hill then down hill. I think that Amy G has the right idea of slowing down when passing.

As for this particular incident, I think that you, the mountain biker, should have slowed down and stopped. However there was no need for the hiker to use profanities, and throw a nut at you. Or did they bust a nut on you?
Ice Tea
2:01:47 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
I always stop and yield to anyone.

On bike paths around DC, you have to signal that you are passing somone, like so; "ON YOUR LEFT", and then they say "OK A-HOLE". My point is that you can't win! Peds think they own the road.

Just respect others, and do unto them as you would have done unto yourself.

I have been run off some single track by other bikers, that pisses me off, so I don't do it to anyone else.

It's easy if you are just compassionate towards others!
CX
2:11:46 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
"Always yeild to a Ped (unless you are on a horse)" m Words to live by.
PedXing
2:23:49 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Wrong answer REPTILES! The only thing you said with validity was that "sometimes it's situational though". The ascender has right-of-way when backpacking, regarless of your beliefs or interpretations. Dunk has it right. If I'm huffin up a mtn trail pack-laiden and you come running/hiking down the same trail, one of 2 thangs're gonna happen. Either you'll hit a few feet of cross-country, or we'll both be floppin down the mtn. I guess you can understand my agitation if the latter were to occur. Naturally if you were to be barreling down toward me on a bike, I'd value the proper condition of my limbs and present quantity of blood, so I'd most certainly step outa the way! Same goes for a bike climbing the trail toward my backside, as a courtesy I'd let 'em (or her, PC now!) by so as not to await my slow, tedious climbing. I very much dislike confrontation, but I'll speak my peace of mind to a fool! (No worries Jim Flink, I don't throw nuts.)

In the words of Ernest T. Bass: I don't throw rocks, I throw bricks!

hehehe
naked ape
2:35:21 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
I, for one, would yield to a biker going downhill. I know he's on a roll. BUT, I would expect he slow down, acknowledge the courtesy, and be cogniscent that there may be kids or dogs or other unpredictable beings in my party.
SLOW DOWN FLINK. No hiker wants to get mixed up with you when (if) you wipe out. Keep in mind that if you startle someone, they may involuntarily become defensive. (the old fight or flight response to perceived danger) Many of us are out there to relax and enjoy ourselves. You're out there for thrills.
flyguy6x
2:38:41 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Wow, I come back from lunch and find a raging debate!

thanks for the links to the rules, everyone. But I have to agree with REPTILES. There's situations where the rules don't make sense. Obviously a biker should be cautious when rounding a bend, but if i'm cruising down a hill and slam on the brakes, chances are I'll fly over the handle bars. It makes more sense to me to have the hiker take 2 seconds to step to the side.

And anyway, in real life, who REALLY feels like asserting their right-of-way when they're a pedestrian? I always feel I'm much safer actively avoiding cars, bikes, horses (okay, never had to avoid a horse, but I would), etc. So it seems like there's a "legal" set of rules, and then a real-life, practical set of rules.
Jim Flink
2:48:32 PM
4/20/01

RE: Trail right of way
Do you yield to naked women?
(.)(.)
) . (
( Y )

Login Form

Username:
Password:

 

 

Post a New Thread
Search Threads
Browse Archive

Create a New Account

Trail Talk Main Page


Search

Search thebackpacker.com for:


Ready to Buy Gear?

Sponsored Links

Great Outdoor Sites

Posters



Links

  • Phil's Photo Page

  •